Critics, particularly from orthodox Hindu groups, argue that Sai baba, despite his popularity, does not conform to traditional Hindu deities and that his worship of Hindu gods distorts the faith's practices. They assert that only established gods from the Hindu pantheon should be venerated in temples, and view Sai Baba's inclusion as inappropriate. This has led to tensions between those who revere Sai baba and those who oppose his worship in temples.
The removal and immersion of Sai Baba's statues in the ganga River, a sacred act in hinduism, are symbolic gestures aimed at purifying the temples. However, this has sparked controversy and hurt the sentiments of Sai Baba’s devotees, who view him as an embodiment of religious harmony, as Sai baba was known to blend elements of both hinduism and islam in his teachings. This issue reflects deeper divisions within Hindu society regarding religious orthodoxy and inclusivity.